ABSTRACT
Objective:To compare the efficacy between intramedullary nailing (IMN) and minimally invasive percutaneous pate oteosynthesis (MIPPO) in the treatment of distal tibial fractures.Methods:China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Database, Chinese Biomedical Literature Database, Pubmed, Embase, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases were searched by computer for publications on IMN and MIPPO in the treatment of distal tibial fractures published in official journals at home and abroad from January 2010 to August 2020. The studies included were evaluated by 2 authors using the Cochrane collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias. The main extraction indexes were operation time, union time, superficial infection, deep infection, malunion, delayed union or nonunion, and soft tissue irritation. Review Manager 5.3 software was used for data analysis.Results:A total of 7 studies with 653 patients were included, with 325 in the IMN group and 328 in the MIPPO group. Meta analysis showed the following: operation time in the IMN group was significantly shorter than that in the MIPPO group ( MD=-10.75, 95% CI:-19.92~-1.58, P=0.02); superficial infection rate in the IMN group was significantly lower than that in the MIPPO group ( RR=0.58, 95% CI: 0.39~0.88, P=0.01); fracture malunion rate in the IMN group was significantly higher than that in the MIPPO group ( RR=1.87, 95% CI: 1.15~3.04, P=0.01). Concerning soft tissue irritation, incidence of anterior knee pain in the IMN group was significantly higher than that in the MIPPO group ( RR=16.98, 95% CI: 3.30~87.34, P=0.0007) while incidence of soft tissue irritation at the fracture site in the IMN group was significantly lower than that in the MIPPO group ( RR=0.13, 95% CI: 0.04~0.40, P=0.0004). There were no significant differences between the 2 groups in fracture healing time, deep infection rate, delayed union rate or nonunion rate ( P>0.05). Conclusions:Although both IMN and MIPPO are fine treatments of distal tibial fractures, IMN may be superior in prevention of superficial tissue infection but prone to anterior knee pain while MIPPO may be superior in prevention of malunion but prone to soft tissue irritation at the fracture site. Therefore, MIPPO is suggested in cases with fine pretibial soft tissues while IMN is used to reduce soft tissue infection otherwise.
ABSTRACT
Introducción: Las fracturas distales de tibia son un desafío terapéutico debido a la escasa cobertura y la particular vascularización. Los objetivos de este estudio son analizar los resultados clínicos y funcionales de los pacientes con fractura de tibia distal, tratados con técnica MIPO con placas bloqueadas; comparar los resultados del grupo de fracturas AO 43A con el de fracturas AO 43C1-C2; y comparar los resultados de la técnica MIPO con el tratamiento abierto convencional. Materiales y Métodos: Entre 2004 y 2012, se evaluaron 32 fracturas de tibia distal tratadas con la técnica MIPO. El 59,4% tenía fracturas AO 43A y el 40,6%, AO 43C. Seguimiento promedio: 39.6 meses, mediante la escala de la AOFAS y radiología. Se consignaron las complicaciones. Se compararon los resultados de los grupos AO A y AO C. Resultados: El grupo AO A: media de 95,89 puntos en la escala AOFAS, en el posoperatorio. El grupo AO C1-2: media de 92,15 puntos en el posoperatorio. Carga del peso corporal: a las 8.7 semanas promedio. Comparación entre AO 43A y AO 43C: p = 0,46 (no significativa). Retorno a la actividad previa a la lesión: 9.3 meses promedio. Comparación entre tipo A y tipo C: p = 0,16 (no significativa). Se detectaron complicaciones en el 18,75% y se retiró la osteosíntesis en 14 casos. Conclusiones: La osteosíntesis mínimamente invasiva con placa y tornillos es una buena opción para las fracturas de tibia distal; con buena evolución clínico-funcional y escasas complicaciones cuando se la compara con la cirugía abierta. Las fracturas 43A presentan menos complicaciones mayores que las 43C, tratadas con la técnica MIPO. Nivel de evidencia: IV.
Introduction: Distal tibial fractures are a therapeutic challenge due to the limited coverage and specific vascularization. The aims of this study are to analyze the clinical outcome and functional results in patients with tibial fracture treated with MIPO technique with locked plates, and to compare AO 43A and AO 43C1-C2 fracture results, and conventional open treatment with MIPO technique. Methods: Between 2004 and 2012, 32 distal tibial fractures treated with MIPO technique were evaluated. The 59.4% were AO 43A fractures and 40.6% were AO 43C. Mean follow-up: 39.6 months using AOFAS Score and X-rays. Complications were recorded. Results in AO A and AO C groups were compared. Results: Mean postoperative AOFAS score was 95.89 and 92.15 in AO A fracture and AO C1-2 fractures respectively. The mean time of weight bearing was 8.7 weeks. The mean time to return to activities was 9.3 months. Complications were detected in the 18.75% and removal of the hardware was necessary in 14 cases. Conclusions: Minimally invasive plate osteosynthesis is a good choice for tibial distal fractures, clinical and functional outcomes are good, and there are fewer complications in comparison to open surgery. AO 43A fractures have less complications than AO 43C with this technique. Level of evidence: IV.
Subject(s)
Adult , Ankle Injuries , Fracture Fixation, Internal/methods , Tibial Fractures/surgery , Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures , Follow-Up Studies , Treatment OutcomeABSTRACT
Distal tibial fractures (Distal tibial fracture) is a common clinical fractures type, more for high-energy damage, fracture type is more complicated. Because of the distal tibia special anatomic structure (soft tissue is less, less blood supply), if the operation method is not suitable or fixed equipment selection is not reasonable, because fracture healing, osteomyelitis, also can damage the function of the ankle joint. Treatment shall be based on the fracture position, type, in the process of the polluted situation and surrounding soft tissue trauma injury and so on many factors that determine the way and the internal fixation methods. This paper reviews recent year different types of distal tibial fracture fixation and fixed ways of literature research, in the treatment of distal tibial fracture clinical practice to provide the reference of objective reasonably select fixation and evaluation standard.
ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to analyze the radiographic and clinical results of intramedullary nailing after percutaneous reduction using pointed reduction forceps for spiral or oblique fractures of the distal tibia. The benefit of percutaneous reduction using pointed reduction forceps in anatomical reduction and maintenance was assessed. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From January 2005 to December 2009, 47 cases of distal one-third tibial fracture were managed by intramedullary nailing using pointed reduction forceps. Thirty-eight cases were spiral fracture and nine cases were oblique fracture. In all cases, the percutaneous reduction was achieved using pointed reduction forceps under fluoroscopy control. While maintaining the reduction with the pointed reduction forceps, the intramedullary nail was inserted. The pointed reduction forceps were removed after insertion of proximal and distal inter-locking screws. Alignment was evaluated with anterior-posterior and lateral radiographs taken immediately post-operation and at the time of union. RESULTS: At immediate post-operation, the mean displacement of valgus and anterior angulation was 0.57degrees and 0.24degrees, respectively. That of valgus and anterior angulation at bone union was 0.37degrees and 0.16degrees, respectively. The average duration of bone union was 16.1 weeks. CONCLUSION: Intramedullary nailing with percutaneous reduction using pointed reduction forceps for distal tibial fractures was an easy and effective method for achievement of accurate alignment intra-operatively. Accurate alignment was successfully maintained until bone union.
Subject(s)
Fluoroscopy , Fracture Fixation, Intramedullary , Surgical Instruments , Tibia , Tibial FracturesABSTRACT
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to analyze the clinical features of distal tibia fractures and to evaluate the treatment outcomes of minimally invasive plate osteosynthesis (MIPO). MATERIALS AND METHODS: From January 2004 to December 2009, 84 cases of 81 patients treated with plate fixation for distal tibia fracture were enrolled in this retrospective review. We investigated age, sex, injury mechanism, fracture patterns, and complications, and the clinical features were analyzed. To evaluate the treatment outcomes of MIPO, we divided into two groups. MIPO group consisted of 55 patients were treated with MIPO technique and conventional group consisted of 18 patients were treated with open reduction and internal fixation with conventional anterolateral plating. The results were compared between two groups by assessing bony union time, operation time, amount of blood loss, range of ankle motion, clinical score by American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, and post-operative complications. RESULTS: The mean age of 81 patients with distal tibia fracture was 54.8 years. According to AO classification, A1:2:3 were 16, 20, 16 patients, B1:2:3 were 2, 8, 7, C1:2:3 were 1, 3, 11 patients. According to injury mechanism, slip down injury was patients, traffic accident was 26, fall from height injury was 14 patients respectively. The type A fractures were lower energy trauma and more older patients. The type C fractures were higher energy trauma and younger patients. MIPO group was better than conventional group in operative time, blood loss, bony union time, and ankle joint motion. In complications, MIPO group showed no nonunion and infection, one malunion, one skin necrosis, nine skin irritations, and one screw breakage. Conventional group showed two nonunion, four infections, two skin necrosis, and one metal failure. CONCLUSION: Distal tibial fractures caused by low energy trauma were on the increase. Minimal invasive plate osteosynthesis was shorter bony union time and operation time, less blood loss, and larger ankle motions than conventional open reduction and plate fixation.
Subject(s)
Animals , Humans , Accidents, Traffic , Ankle , Ankle Joint , Foot , Necrosis , Operative Time , Retrospective Studies , Skin , Tibia , Tibial FracturesABSTRACT
Objective To evaluate the short-term outcomes of minimally invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis(MIPPO) combined with locking compression plate(LCP) in the treatment of distal tibial fractures.Methods From June 2004 to March 2006,16 patients with distal tibial fractures were treated using MIPPO combined with LCP in our department.According to the AO classification,there were 7 cases of type 43A1,5 type 43A3,2 type 43B1 and 2 type 43C3.After reduction of tibial fracture with three methods,LCP was inserted and fixed with locking screw.All the cases were followed up periodically after the operation.Results All the cases were followed up for 5 to 20 months(mean,11.5 months).Primary wound healing was achieved in 16 patients.No complications,such as non-union,abnormal union and breakage of the plate,occurred in the cases.Callus formation was seen on X-rays at 7.6 weeks(4 to 12 weeks) after the surgery,when the patients began part weight-bearing exercises.The bone union was detected at 16 weeks(8 to 20 weeks),when the patients began full weight bearing.3 patients felt uncomfortable at the distal tibia around the implant.According to the AOFAS Ankle-Hindfoot Scale,14 cases(87.5%) were excellent and 2(12.5%) were good.Conclusions MIPPO combined with LCP technique is an effective treatment for the fractures of the distal tibia.This minimally invasive method can achieve stable fixation,promote bone healing,and permit early functional rehabilitation.
ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: To analyze the biomechanical effects of different frame configurations of the hybrid external fixators for distal tibial fractures on the frame stiffness and stress distribution with a finite element method (FEM). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Five configurations were simulated: Group I: two wires with convergence angle of 60degrees, Group II: 3rd wire on a bisector axis of the group I. Group III: two wires with 30degrees. Group IV: 3rd wire on a bisector axis. Group V: two wires with 30degree and a half pin on the distal articular fragment. Each group was simulated under compression, torsion, anterior-posterior and lateral-medial bending load. Stiffness, stress and deformation values were calculated. RESULTS: The overall stiffness was increased by 15~30% with the addition of a third wire, and by 150~400% with a anteromedial half pin on the articular fragment. The half pin decreased the stress level of the frame by about 43% and the deformation of the 5/8 ring by about 30%. CONCLUSION: The addition of a half pin on the articular fragment is not only a method of increasing the stiffness but also a way of decreasing the stress concentration and the deformation of the frame.